From 7K to 70K Followers: How to Grow on Instagram with Authentic Content | with Amanda Otterman
What if the secret to growing on Instagram isn't creating more polished content, following every trend, or spending hours editing Reels, but learning how to connect with your audience in a way that feels genuinely you?
In this episode of Modern Marketing Made Simple, I'm sitting down with Amanda Otterman, registered nurse, personal trainer, and founder of MenoHealth Nurse, to talk about Instagram growth strategies, authentic content creation, and how building a personal brand around your expertise can open doors you never expected.
Amanda shares how she found her niche in women's health, began creating content around the conversations she was already having with clients, and eventually created a simple Instagram Reel that reached millions of people. That one Reel helped grow her audience from approximately 7,000 to more than 70,000 followers and introduced her work to an entirely new audience.
But this conversation is about so much more than how to go viral on Instagram Reels.
We talk about what happened before that viral moment, why authentic content can be more powerful than perfectly produced videos, and how Amanda turned her growing Instagram following into clients, speaking opportunities, industry connections, and even a book deal to write Menopause For Dummies.
If you're a small business owner or entrepreneur trying to figure out how to grow on Instagram, find your niche, or build a personal brand that attracts the right people, this episode offers a real-life look at what organic Instagram growth can make possible.
In This Episode
→ How to find your niche in business by paying attention to the people you already serve
→ Why authentic content creation is an important part of building a recognizable personal brand
→ The story behind Amanda's viral Instagram Reel and how it helped her grow from 7K to 70K followers
→ Instagram growth strategies that focus on relatable content rather than perfect production
→ How to stand out on Instagram by developing your own voice and perspective
→ Why building trust on social media matters before trying to sell
→ How Amanda turned Instagram followers into coaching clients, workshop participants, and customers
→ The role of networking, community, and real-world connections in growing an online business
→ How a strong personal brand can lead to speaking opportunities, collaborations, and unexpected business growth
→ Overcoming imposter syndrome and giving yourself permission to show up as the expert you already are
Amanda's story is a reminder that you don't need to be the most polished person on Instagram to make an impact. You need to understand who you're speaking to, create content that resonates, and be willing to show up as yourself.
Connect with Amanda:
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/menohealthnurse
Website: www.menohealthnurse.com
Want another example of how relatable Instagram content can help grow a business?
Listen to my conversation with Natalie, founder of Rinkside Mom, where we talk about niche marketing, building an engaged community, and using relatable content to grow a recognizable brand.
How to Build a Community on Instagram Using a Niche Marketing Strategy
_________________________________
✨ WANT TO MAKE SOCIAL MEDIA SIMPLER?
You don't need to spend hours creating content, chasing trends, or trying to figure out what to post next.
Inside the Modern Marketing Hub, you'll find practical social media strategies, fresh content ideas, audience growth training, and resources to help you build your brand and grow your business.
Think of it as having a social media manager in your pocket.
👉 Join the Modern Marketing Hub: JOIN NOW
🎙️ HAVE A BUSINESS STORY WORTH SHARING?
The Modern Marketing Podcast features real conversations with women building businesses, sharing the lessons they've learned, the challenges they've faced, and the strategies that have helped them grow.
If you're a small business owner, social seller, or personal brand with a story that could inspire and teach other entrepreneurs, I'd love to hear from you.
👉 Apply to be a podcast guest: APPLY NOW
LET'S CONNECT!
I'm Lori Ervin, founder of Level Up Marketing Co., where I help women building online businesses simplify their social media, create content that connects, and turn their marketing into meaningful business growth.
Through done-for-you social media management, content creation, and the Modern Marketing Hub, I help make marketing feel a whole lot more manageable.
Follow along for practical social media tips, content ideas, marketing strategies, and a behind-the-scenes look at building a business.
📱 Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/theloriervin
🌐 Website: https://www.loriervin.com
_________________________________
Episode Chapters
00:00 – Meet Amanda Otterman and her entrepreneurial journey
01:15 – From nursing burnout to starting a fitness business
03:26 – Finding a niche by listening to your ideal clients
07:37 – How community workshops created new business opportunities
09:48 – Overcoming the fear of putting yourself out there
11:25 – The power of networking and finding the right rooms
13:17 – Overcoming imposter syndrome: "I belong in the room"
15:11 – Creating intentional Instagram content and using AI tools
16:49 – From 7K to 40K followers with one viral Instagram Reel
17:07 – How Amanda created her viral Reel in just 20 minutes
18:33 – What happened when her Instagram Reel reached millions
19:20 – Handling negative comments and protecting your online space
20:03 – Turning Instagram followers into paying clients
20:45 – Why authentic content and connection matter more than selling
22:22 – Why you need to take risks to stand out on Instagram
23:04 – How a viral Reel led to industry recognition and speaking opportunities
25:58 – Rebranding and building a personal brand around your expertise
27:06 – How Instagram visibility led to a book deal
32:06 – Amanda's biggest advice for growing an authentic personal brand
33:47 – The reality behind overnight success and business growth
35:06 – Amanda's mission to support women through menopause
37:15 – Where to connect with Amanda
