How to Build Customer Loyalty and Increase Repeat Sales

What if one of the best ways to grow your small business isn't finding more customers, but building stronger relationships with the ones you already have?

As small business owners, we spend a lot of time thinking about how to attract new customers. We're creating social media content, trying to grow our email lists, experimenting with different marketing strategies, and looking for new ways to get our businesses in front of more people.

And while attracting new customers is important, there's another part of business growth that deserves just as much attention: customer loyalty and retention.

How do you turn someone who purchases from you once into someone who comes back again and again? How do you create an experience that makes customers feel connected to your business? And how can you increase repeat sales without constantly offering discounts or chasing the next new customer?

These are some of the things I explored in my conversation with Shannon, the owner of Smithery Style, on the Modern Marketing Podcast.

After spending years working in corporate PR and marketing, Shannon purchased Smithery Style, an established online fashion business that helps women find clothing that works for their body shape. Since taking over the business, she's introduced creative customer loyalty strategies designed to strengthen relationships, encourage repeat purchases, and build a community around the brand.

What I love about Shannon's approach is that she's not relying on one complicated marketing strategy. She's finding practical ways to make customers feel valued, involve them in the business, and give them reasons to keep coming back.

And while Smithery Style is a product-based business, so many of these lessons can be applied to service-based businesses, personal brands, and social sellers, too.

1. Build a Customer Community, Not Just a Customer List

One of the most interesting strategies Shannon shared was how she created the Smithery Inner Circle.

She started by identifying approximately 400 of her top customers and inviting them to become part of a more exclusive community. Of those invited, 89 joined. Rather than building an entirely new platform or complicated membership program, Shannon used a feature she already had access to: Instagram Close Friends.

Inside the Inner Circle, customers get a more personal connection to Smithery Style. Shannon can ask questions, share updates, gather feedback, and involve these women in decisions about the business. Members also receive an exclusive discount as a thank-you for being part of the community.

This is a great example of how to build a customer community without needing a large budget or complicated technology.

But what makes this strategy particularly effective isn't simply the exclusive access or discount. It's the fact that customers have an opportunity to participate in the brand. They're not just watching Shannon promote clothing. They're being invited into conversations, sharing their opinions, and helping shape the shopping experience. That kind of involvement can create a much stronger connection than simply following a business on Instagram.

Community building for business doesn't always mean creating something big. Sometimes it means creating a smaller space where your most engaged customers feel recognized, appreciated, and involved.

Try this in your business:

Think about the customers or clients who have already demonstrated that they love what you do. These might be people who purchase regularly, refer others, engage with your content, or consistently support your business.

How could you create a more personal experience for them?

For a product-based business, that might mean an Instagram Close Friends list where customers get early access to new products, exclusive previews, or opportunities to share feedback.

For a service-based business, it could mean inviting past clients to a private Q&A, offering early access to new services, or creating a referral community.

And for social sellers, it might be a smaller customer group where you share product education, helpful tips, and opportunities for customers to ask questions.

The goal isn't necessarily to create another thing to manage. It's to strengthen relationships with people who already have a connection to your business.

2. Use Email Marketing to Encourage Repeat Sales

Another important part of Shannon's customer retention strategy is her email marketing.

She recognizes that not every customer has the same level of connection to her business. Someone who follows Smithery Style on Instagram might be interested in the brand, but that relationship looks different from someone who has subscribed to her emails or joined her Inner Circle.

Shannon has created different opportunities for customers to deepen their relationship with the business. Her email subscribers receive special benefits, including exclusive offers on new product launches. One strategy she shared involves offering subscribers 15% off newly launched products for a limited period.

It's a simple approach, but there are several reasons it can work.

First, it gives people a reason to subscribe to her email list. They're not simply signing up to receive another promotional message. They're getting access to something valuable. Second, it gives existing subscribers a reason to open her emails and pay attention when new collections arrive. And third, the limited-time nature of the offer creates a reason to make a purchasing decision rather than putting it off indefinitely.

This is an important lesson in how to increase repeat sales without relying on constant promotions. Instead of discounting everything all the time, Shannon uses specific offers for specific audiences at specific moments. 

Her approach also highlights why email marketing for small businesses is so valuable. Unlike social media, where an algorithm influences how many followers see your content, your email list gives you a more direct way to communicate with people who have chosen to hear from you.

Of course, having an email list doesn't automatically create customer loyalty. What matters is how you use it.

The goal of email marketing shouldn't simply be to sell something every time you show up in someone's inbox. It should be to build a relationship that makes people want to keep hearing from you.

Try this in your business:

If you already have an email list, think about how you're using it to nurture existing customers, not just attract new ones.

Could you create a special offer for returning customers? Give subscribers first access to a new product or service? Share useful advice that helps customers get more value from something they've already purchased?

You could also segment your list based on customer behaviour. Someone who has purchased from you three times might benefit from different emails than someone who has never made a purchase.

And if you don't have an email list yet, consider what would make someone genuinely want to join.

It doesn't always need to be a free download. Early access, exclusive content, helpful education, and special customer experiences can all give people a reason to subscribe.

3. Create Customer Experiences That Give People a Reason to Come Back

One of my favourite parts of this conversation was hearing about the Smithery Vault.

Rather than continuing to rely entirely on traditional pop-up markets and other people's events, Shannon began creating her own shopping experiences.

The Smithery Vault brings customers together for an opportunity to shop, connect with the brand, and discover other participating businesses. Shannon has also incorporated partnerships and sponsors into these events.

What's interesting about this approach is that she's doing more than creating another opportunity to sell clothing. She's creating an experience that customers can look forward to. And because it's her event, she has more control over the atmosphere, the customer experience, the participating businesses, and how the event is promoted.

This is a smart example of event marketing for small businesses because it brings together several marketing goals at once.

It creates an opportunity to generate sales, strengthen relationships with existing customers, introduce the business to new people, and collaborate with other brands that serve a similar audience. It also gives customers another way to experience Smithery Style beyond scrolling through products online.

For online businesses especially, finding ways to create those personal connections can make a meaningful difference.

People may discover your business because of a product or service, but the experience they have with your brand can influence whether they remember you, recommend you, and return.

Try this in your business:

You don't need to host a large event to apply this strategy. Start by thinking about the type of experience your customers would genuinely enjoy.

A product-based business could host a seasonal shopping event, product demonstration, virtual launch party, or customer appreciation evening.

A service provider might offer a small workshop, client appreciation event, or educational session that brings together people with similar goals.

Social sellers could organize product experience evenings, themed shopping events, or collaborations with complementary businesses.

You could even partner with another business that serves a similar audience to create something neither of you would have organized alone.

The important question is: What could you create that gives people a reason to spend time with your business, beyond simply making a purchase?

4. Listen to Your Customers and Make It Easier for Them to Buy

Another theme that came up throughout my conversation with Shannon was the importance of paying attention to what customers actually need.

One of the advantages of her Inner Circle is that she has a group of engaged customers she can ask for feedback. Rather than making every business decision based on assumptions, she can start conversations, ask questions, and learn more about what her customers want. These customer feedback strategies can help her make more informed decisions about products, promotions, and the overall shopping experience.

And that's especially important when customer spending habits are changing.

Shannon also talked about the need to adapt during challenging economic conditions. She's explored different approaches to marketing and sales, worked with suppliers, and looked for creative ways to make shopping more accessible. One example is her approach to curated collections. Rather than expecting customers to sort through a large selection of clothing and figure everything out for themselves, Smithery Style introduced a smaller collection of versatile pieces called Smithery Staples.

This helps simplify the shopping experience by giving customers a more manageable starting point.

It's a reminder that small business marketing isn't always about convincing more people to buy. Sometimes it's about making the buying process easier for people who are already interested.

When customers feel overwhelmed by too many choices, unclear information, or uncertainty about which product or service is right for them, they may delay making a decision. Helping them understand their options can remove some of that hesitation.

Try this in your business:

Think about the questions customers ask before purchasing from you.

Are they unsure which product to choose? Do they struggle to understand the differences between your services? Are there common concerns that prevent them from making a decision?

Use those questions to improve the way you market and present your offers.

A product-based business could create a curated collection of bestsellers, a gift guide, or a simple comparison of popular products.

A service provider might simplify their packages, create a clear starting offer, or explain exactly who each service is designed for.

Social sellers could create product routines, starter bundles, or educational content that helps customers choose the right products for their needs.

You can also use Instagram polls, email surveys, customer conversations, and post-purchase follow-ups to learn what people want more of. The more you understand your customers, the easier it becomes to create marketing that speaks directly to their needs.

Key Takeaways: How to Build Customer Loyalty and Increase Repeat Sales

If you're looking for practical customer retention strategies to grow your small business, here are five lessons you can take from Shannon's experience:

1. Focus on the customers you already have. Attracting new customers matters, but strengthening existing relationships can create opportunities for repeat purchases, referrals, and long-term growth.
2. Create opportunities for customers to feel involved. An exclusive customer community, VIP group, or regular feedback opportunity can help people feel more connected to your business.
3. Use email marketing to nurture relationships. Give subscribers reasons to stay engaged through helpful content, exclusive access, and thoughtful offers rather than sending promotional emails alone.
4. Make the customer experience part of your marketing strategy. Events, collaborations, personal interactions, and memorable shopping experiences can help your business stand out.
5. Listen to your customers and simplify the buying process. Customer feedback, curated offers, and clear product education can help you make better business decisions while making it easier for people to purchase.

One of the biggest lessons from Shannon's approach is that customer loyalty doesn't have to come from an elaborate customer loyalty program. It can come from consistently making people feel appreciated, creating opportunities for connection, and paying attention to what they need.

And when you start approaching your marketing with those relationships in mind, you're not just thinking about how to make the next sale. You're building a business that gives people reasons to keep coming back.

Listen to the full episode here:

Connect with Shannon:

Follow along and support Smithery Style:

Instagram: Smithery Style - https://www.instagram.com/smitherystyle/ 

Website: https://www.smitherystyle.com

Want More? Let's Talk About Creating Customer Experiences That Build Your Brand

If you enjoyed learning about Shannon's customer loyalty strategies, I think you'll also love my conversation with Fharas, the founder of A1 Rituals.

Fharas shares how she grew her product-based business through storytelling, strategic gifting, word-of-mouth marketing, and creating memorable customer experiences.

From giving away 84 candles to building relationships through in-person markets, her experience offers another perspective on how small businesses can get their products into people's hands, build meaningful connections, and create opportunities for growth.

Listen to: How to Grow a Product-Based Business Through Storytelling, Gifting & Customer Experience | A1 Rituals

It's a great follow-up to Shannon's conversation because both women demonstrate that growing a product-based business involves more than simply having something great to sell. The relationships you create, the experiences you offer, and the way you make customers feel can all influence how your brand grows.

_________________________

Want to Make Social Media Simpler?

You don't need to spend hours creating content, chasing trends, or trying to figure out what to post next.

Inside the Modern Marketing Hub, you'll find practical social media strategies, fresh content ideas, audience growth training, and resources to help you build your brand and grow your business.

Think of it as having a social media manager in your pocket.

JOIN NOW

Have a Business Story Worth Sharing?

The Modern Marketing Podcast features real conversations with women building businesses, sharing the lessons they've learned, the challenges they've faced, and the strategies that have helped them grow.

If you're a small business owner, social seller, or personal brand with a story that could inspire and teach other entrepreneurs, I'd love to hear from you.

APPLY NOW

Let's Connect!

I'm Lori Ervin, founder of Level Up Marketing Co., where I help women building online businesses simplify their social media, create content that connects, and turn their marketing into meaningful business growth.

Through done-for-you social media management, content creation, and the Modern Marketing Hub, I help make marketing feel a whole lot more manageable.

Follow along for practical social media tips, content ideas, marketing strategies, and a behind-the-scenes look at building a business.

Instagram: www.instagram.com/theloriervin

Website: www.loriervin.com