How to Build a Community on Instagram Using a Niche Marketing Strategy
What if the reason your Instagram content isn't connecting isn't because you need better graphics, more Reels, or a bigger marketing budget, but because you're trying to speak to too many people?
For small business owners, one of the biggest challenges with social media marketing is figuring out how to stand out. There are thousands of businesses creating content every day, and getting someone to stop scrolling, pay attention, and actually care about your brand can feel difficult.
But sometimes, getting more specific about who you're speaking to can make all the difference.
In this episode of Modern Marketing Made Simple, I sat down with Natalie, founder of Rinkside Mom, to talk about how she built a growing business by creating content for one very specific audience: hockey moms.
Her story is a great example of how niche marketing, relatable content, and community-first marketing can work together to build a brand that people feel genuinely connected to.
You Don't Have to Market to Everyone
One of the most interesting parts of my conversation with Natalie was her approach to choosing a target audience.
She shared a concept that has guided the way she builds her brand. You can go an inch deep and a mile wide, or an inch wide and a mile deep.
For Natalie, the decision was to go deep.
Rather than trying to create apparel and content for every sports parent, she focused specifically on hockey moms. She understood their schedules, their experiences, their friendships, and all the little moments that make being a hockey mom so unique.
And because she is part of that audience herself, she knows exactly what resonates.
This is an important lesson for anyone trying to figure out how to find their target audience.
You don't necessarily need to appeal to more people to grow your business. Sometimes you can build a stronger brand by becoming more relevant to a specific group of people.
That doesn't mean niche marketing is the only successful strategy. But for Natalie, being incredibly clear about who she serves has been a defining part of her growth.
Try this in your business: Think about the person you most want to attract. What experiences do they have that others might not understand? What challenges, conversations, or everyday moments could you speak to more specifically?
The more clearly you understand your audience, the easier it becomes to create content that feels relevant to them.
Relatable Content Gives People a Reason to Share
One of the things I love about Natalie's Instagram strategy is how simple so much of her content is. She's not constantly creating elaborate Reels or spending hours trying to produce perfectly polished graphics.
Instead, she pays attention to the moments that hockey moms experience and turns those into relatable posts. The excitement of tournament weekends. The stress of tryouts. The endless hockey schedules. The friendships that develop between families.
They're moments that make other hockey moms stop scrolling and think, "That's exactly how I feel."
And then they share them.
This is an important part of learning how to create relatable content for your own business.
Content doesn't always need to educate or sell. Sometimes its job is simply to make your audience feel understood.
When someone shares your post with a friend, adds it to their Stories, or sends it to a group chat, they're introducing your business to other people who may have similar interests.
That's one way creating shareable Instagram content can help you grow your following organically.
Try this in your business: Instead of asking yourself what you should post about your product or service today, ask:
- What is my audience experiencing right now?
- What would make them laugh, nod, or say, "That's so true"?
- What would they want to send to a friend who understands?
Start creating content around those moments.
Build a Community, Not Just a Following
One of the most interesting things about Rinkside Mom is that the community came before the products.
Natalie started by creating content that hockey moms connected with. As that community grew, she introduced hats and apparel that gave women another way to identify with the brand.
She described the feeling of seeing another mom wearing Rinkside Mom apparel at a rink. There's an instant connection because they both understand what the brand represents. The product is more than a hat or sweatshirt. It's something that represents a shared experience. This is a great example of community-first marketing.
Rather than focusing every piece of content on making a sale, Natalie created a reason for people to care about her brand first. And when she introduced products, they made sense to the community she had already built.
For small businesses, this is an important distinction: your Instagram audience is made up of people, not just potential transactions.
When people feel connected to your business, they're more likely to remember it, engage with your content, recommend it to others, and consider supporting it when they're ready to buy.
Try this in your business: Look at your current Instagram content. How much of it is focused on promoting what you sell, and how much is focused on connecting with the people you want to reach?
Consider creating more content that reflects your audience's interests, values, and experiences, even when it doesn't directly promote a product.
Strategic Collaborations Can Help You Reach the Right People
Natalie has also used collaborations and giveaways to help grow Rinkside Mom.
But what makes her approach interesting is how intentional she is about choosing the right partners and prizes. Rather than running generic giveaways designed to attract as many people as possible, she thinks about what hockey moms would genuinely appreciate.
In one example, she gave away gift cards for new sneakers and women's apparel because she recognized how often moms prioritize buying things for their children instead of themselves. The giveaway resonated because it reflected a real experience within her community.
She also looks for collaboration partners whose audiences overlap with hers, even if those businesses aren't directly related to hockey. This helped her to grow her audience.
This is an important lesson in Instagram collaborations for small businesses.
The goal isn't always to reach the largest possible audience. It's to reach people who are genuinely likely to connect with your business.
Try this in your business: Identify three businesses or creators who serve a similar audience without offering exactly what you sell.
Consider whether you could collaborate on content, introduce each other to your communities, or create a giveaway that would be genuinely valuable to both audiences.
Key Takeaways: How to Build a Brand on Instagram
If you're trying to grow a small business on social media, here are five lessons you can take from Natalie's experience:
- Get clear on your target audience. Knowing exactly who you're speaking to can make your content more relevant and your brand more recognizable.
- Create content people want to share. Relatable experiences, emotions, and everyday moments can help introduce your business to new audiences.
- Make connection part of your marketing strategy. Not every post needs to sell something. Building relationships can support long-term brand loyalty.
- Choose collaborations intentionally. Look for businesses and creators who share your target audience, rather than focusing only on follower counts.
- Don't overcomplicate content creation. Some of Natalie's most successful posts came from simple ideas that reflected exactly what her community was experiencing.
The biggest takeaway from this conversation is that building a brand on social media doesn't have to mean doing more of everything. Sometimes, it means understanding your audience better and creating content that speaks directly to them.
Want to Go Deeper? Listen to the Full Conversation
In this episode of Modern Marketing Made Simple, Natalie shares more about how she started Rinkside Mom, the lessons she's learned from building a product-based business, and how she's using Instagram, collaborations, and in-person events to continue growing her brand.
Listen to the full episode here:
Meet Natalie from Rinkside Mom:
Natalie is the founder of Rinkside Mom, a community-focused apparel brand created for the moms behind the glass. As a hockey mom herself, Natalie built her business around the experiences, friendships, and everyday moments that connect hockey families.
Through relatable Instagram content, collaborations, and a growing collection of apparel, she's created a brand that celebrates the women who do so much for their families both on and off the ice.
Connect with Natalie:
- Instagram: www.instagram.com/rinksidemomco
- Website: www.rinksidemomco.com
Want more? Let's talk about going viral.
Want another real-life example of how content can help grow your audience and build a community? In my conversation with Amanda Otterman, we explore the story behind her viral Instagram Reel and what happened when her content reached people far beyond her existing followers.
It's a great follow-up to Natalie's story because both conversations demonstrate the power of creating content that people genuinely connect with and want to share.
___________________________________
Want to Make Social Media Simpler?
You don't need to spend hours creating content, chasing trends, or trying to figure out what to post next.
Inside the Modern Marketing Hub, you'll find practical social media strategies, fresh content ideas, audience growth training, and resources to help you build your brand and grow your business.
Think of it as having a social media manager in your pocket.
Have a Business Story Worth Sharing?
The Modern Marketing Podcast features real conversations with women building businesses, sharing the lessons they've learned, the challenges they've faced, and the strategies that have helped them grow.
If you're a small business owner, social seller, or personal brand with a story that could inspire and teach other entrepreneurs, I'd love to hear from you.
Let's Connect!
I'm Lori Ervin, founder of Level Up Marketing Co., where I help women building online businesses simplify their social media, create content that connects, and turn their marketing into meaningful business growth.
Through done-for-you social media management, content creation, and the Modern Marketing Hub, I help make marketing feel a whole lot more manageable.
Follow along for practical social media tips, content ideas, marketing strategies, and a behind-the-scenes look at building a business.
Instagram: www.instagram.com/theloriervin
Website: www.loriervin.com
Stay connected with new blog posts, podcast episodes and business tips!
Sign up below to hop on my email list ...not to worry, I don't believe in spam.
